- 2010: Douglas Hodge – La Cage aux Folles com Albin
- Kelsey Grammer – La Cage aux Folles com Georges
- Sean Hayes – Promises, Promises com Chuck Baxter
- Chad Kimball – Memphis com Huey Calhoun
- Sahr Ngaujah – Fela! com Fela Kuti
- 2011: Norbert Leo Butz – Catch Me If You Can com Carl Hanratty
- Josh Gad – The Book of Mormon com Elder Cunningham
- Joshua Henry – The Scottsboro Boys com Haywood Patterson
- Andrew Rannells – The Book of Mormon com Elder Price
- Tony Sheldon – Priscilla, Queen of the Desert com Bernadette
- 2012: Steve Kazee – Once com Guy
- Danny Burstein – Follies com Buddy Plummer
- Jeremy Jordan – Newsies com Jack Kelly
- Norm Lewis – Porgy and Bess com Porgy
- Ron Raines – Follies com Ben Stone
- 2013: Billy Porter - Kinky Boots com Lola
- Bertie Carvel - Matilda The Musical com Miss Trunchbull
- Santino Fontana - Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella com the Prince
- Rob McClure - Chaplin, the musical com Charlie Chaplin
- Stark Sands - Kinky Boots com Charlie Price
- 2014: Neil Patrick Harris - Hedwig and the Angry Inch com a Hedwig Schmidt
- Ramin Karimloo - Les Misérables com a Jean Valjean
- Andy Karl - Rocky the Musical com a Rocky Balboa
- Jefferson Mays - A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder com a The D'Ysquith Family
- Bryce Pinkham - A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder com a Monty Navarro
| - 2015: Michael Cerveris - Fun Home com a Bruce Bechdel
- Brian d'Arcy James - Something Rotten! com a Nick Bottom
- Robert Fairchild - An American in Paris com a Jerry Mulligan
- Ken Watanabe - The King and I com The King of Siam
- Tony Yazbeck - On the Town com a Gabey
- 2017: Ben Platt - Dear Evan Hansen com a Evan Hansen
- Christian Borle - Falsettos com a Marvin
- Josh Groban - Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 com a Pierre Bezukhov
- Andy Karl - Groundhog Day com a Phil Connors
- David Hyde Pierce - Hello, Dolly! com a Horace Vandergelder
- 2018: Tony Shalhoub - The Band's Visit com a Tewfiq Zakaria
- Harry Hadden-Paton - My Fair Lady com a Henry Higgins
- Joshua Henry - Carousel com a Billy Bigelow
- Ethan Slater - SpongeBob SquarePants com a SpongeBob SquarePants
- 2019: Santino Fontana - Tootsie com a Michael Dorsey / Dorothy Michaels
- Brooks Ashmanskas - The Prom com a Barry Glickman
- Derrick Baskin - Ain’t Too Proud com a Otis Williams
- Alex Brightman - Beetlejuice com a Beetlejuice
- Damon Daunno - Oklahoma! com a Curly McLain
|