- 2011 : Kathleen Marshall – Anything Goes
- Rob Ashford – How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- Casey Nicholaw – The Book of Mormon
- Susan Stroman – The Scottsboro Boys
- 2012 : Christopher Gattelli – Newsies
- Rob Ashford – Evita
- Steven Hoggett – Once
- Kathleen Marshall – Nice Work If You Can Get It
- 2013 : Jerry Mitchell – Kinky Boots
- Andy Blankenbuehler – Bring It On: The Musical
- Peter Darling – Matilda the Musical
- Chet Walker – Pippin
- 2014 : Warren Carlyle – After Midnight
- Kelly Devine et Steven Hoggett – Rocky
- Casey Nicholaw – Aladdin
- Susan Stroman – Bullets Over Broadway
- 2015 : Christopher Wheeldon – An American in Paris
- Joshua Bergasse – On the Town
- Christopher Gattelli – Le Roi et moi
- Scott Graham et Steven Hoggett – The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
- Casey Nicholaw – Something Rotten!
| - 2016 : Andy Blankenbuehler – Hamilton
- 2017 : Andy Blankenbuehler – Bandstand
- Peter Darling et Ellen Kane – Groundhog Day
- Kelly Devine – Come from Away
- Denis Jones – Holiday Inn
- Sam Pinkleton – Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812
- 2018 : Justin Peck – Carousel
|