- 1960: Frederick Dvonch – La Mélodie du bonheur
- Abba Bogin – Greenwillow
- Lehman Engel – Take Me Along
- Hal Hastings – Fiorello!
- Milton Rosenstick – Gypsy
- 1961: Franz Allers – Camelot
- Pembroke Davenport – 13 Daughters
- Stanley Lebowsky – Irma La Douce
- Elliot Lawrence – Bye Bye Birdie
- 1962: Elliot Lawrence – How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- Pembrode Davenport – Kean
- Herbert Greene – The Gay Life
- Peter Matz – No Strings
| - 1963: Donald Pippin – Oliver!
- Jay Blackton – Mr. President
- Anton Coppola – Bravo Giovanni
- Julius Rudel – Brigadoon
- 1964: Shepard Coleman – Hello, Dolly!
- Lehman Engel – What Makes Sammy Run?
- Charles Jaffe – West Side Story
- Fred Werner – High Spirits
|